What is the Difference Between Legal Audit and Legal Due Diligence? Detailed Explanation for Legal Practitioners – In the legal world, two terms that are often used in the context of legal analysis are Legal Audit and Legal Due Diligence. While both aim to provide a comprehensive understanding of a legal entity or transaction, their approaches, scope, and objectives are significantly different. This article will provide a detailed explanation of the differences between these two processes, serving as a guide for legal practitioners.

Definitions of Legal Audit and Legal Due Diligence

• Legal Audit
  A Legal Audit is a systematic evaluation of the legal aspects of an existing entity or company. The primary goal of a legal audit is to ensure that the entity complies with all applicable laws and regulations while identifying potential legal risks that may arise in the future.
• Legal Due Diligence
  Legal Due Diligence, on the other hand, is a comprehensive examination of the legal aspects of an entity or transaction, typically conducted before making strategic decisions such as mergers, acquisitions, or major investments. This process aims to uncover legal risks and provide the necessary information for the parties involved in the transaction.

Main Objectives

1. Objectives of Legal Audit

1. Legal Compliance: Ensuring the company adheres to all applicable laws and regulations.
2. Risk Identification: Identifying potential legal violations that could lead to administrative, criminal, or civil sanctions.
3. Recommendations for Improvement: Providing recommendations to improve or strengthen the company’s legal systems.

2. Objectives of Legal Due Diligence

1. Transaction Risk Analysis: Identifying legal risks that may impact the success of a transaction.
2. Valuation Assessment: Providing relevant information to assess the value or feasibility of an investment.
3. Supporting Strategic Decisions: Supplying legal data necessary for making informed business decisions.

Scope of Examination

1. Scope of Legal Audit

A Legal Audit encompasses all legal aspects relevant to a company’s operations, such as:

• Licensing Documents: Validity of business permits, environmental permits, and other necessary documents.
• Labor Regulations: Compliance with labor laws.
• Commercial Contracts: Evaluation of contracts with third parties to ensure legal compliance.
• Tax Compliance: Review of the company’s tax obligations.
• Corporate Governance: Legality of the company’s structure and internal legal documents, such as articles of association.

2. Scope of Legal Due Diligence

Legal Due Diligence focuses on aspects relevant to a specific transaction. For instance, in the context of an acquisition, the scope includes:

• Asset Ownership: Examination of property rights, buildings, or intellectual property.
• Litigation: Analysis of ongoing or potential legal disputes.
• Key Agreements: Evaluation of contracts that could affect the transaction value.
• Legal Liabilities: Identification of debts and other contractual obligations.
• Transaction Compliance: Ensuring the transaction adheres to regulations.

Methodology

1. Methodology of Legal Audit

• Data Collection: Gathering legal and operational documents of the company.
• Interviews: Conducting interviews with management and related parties.
• Legal Analysis: Assessing the extent of the company’s legal compliance.
• Audit Report: Preparing a report containing findings and recommendations for improvement.

2. Methodology of Legal Due Diligence

• Defining the Scope: Determining the legal aspects to be examined based on transaction needs.
• Document Review: Examining documents related to the transaction, such as agreements, financial reports, and supporting documents.
• Consultation with Stakeholders: Involving notaries, lawyers, and other legal consultants to ensure the completeness of the examination.
• Due Diligence Report: Providing a final report that includes findings, risk analysis, and recommendations.

Timing of Execution

• Legal Audit is typically conducted periodically, such as annually or as needed by the company.
• Legal Due Diligence is conducted at specific times, usually before major transactions or strategic decision-making.

Expected Outcomes

1. Legal Audit

The results of a Legal Audit include a report that contains:

• A list of the company’s legal compliance.
• Identification of areas needing improvement.
• Recommendations to mitigate legal risks.

2. Legal Due Diligence

The results of Legal Due Diligence include a report that contains:

• Legal risks associated with the transaction.
• Potential legal liabilities to be considered.
• Feasibility analysis of the transaction from a legal perspective.

Significant Roles in the Legal Field

• Importance of Legal Audit
  Legal Audit helps companies avoid legal issues that could threaten business continuity. It also enhances transparency and good governance.
• Importance of Legal Due Diligence
  Legal Due Diligence serves as the foundation for decision-making in major business transactions. This process ensures that all legal risks have been evaluated before a transaction is finalized.

Legal Audit and Legal Due Diligence are two distinct yet equally important processes in the legal and business world. Legal Audit focuses on evaluating comprehensive legal compliance in a company’s operations, whereas Legal Due Diligence aims to uncover legal risks in the context of a specific transaction. By understanding these differences, legal practitioners can choose the most appropriate method to achieve their desired legal and business objectives.

For more information

Please visit:

www.siemakonsultan.com

Jakarta Office:

Sampoerna Strategic Square

South Tower Level 30,

Jl.Jend.Sudirman Kav.45

Jakarta Selatan – DKI Jakarta

Bali Office: 

Jl. Cokroaminoto No.212,

Ubung, Denpasar Utara,

Bali – Indonesia

Contact Us:

Imam Budiharto
imam@siemakonsultan.com

Telpon: 021 2992 7844

Whatsapp: 0813 1114 2228